21 Comments
User's avatar
Amber Rubenstein's avatar

Thank you Marnie. You are saying what all of the people that I know(of our tribe) are feeling. I am so grateful to people like you and the rest of the brave people who are standing on the battlefield of words and truth. I am so proud to call you my friend.

Amber

Expand full comment
Marnie Perlstein's avatar

❤️❤️❤️❤️

Expand full comment
Janine Pasvolsky's avatar

Marn this is brilliantly written and heartbreaking in its essence. Thank you my friend - very grateful for your insight and downright bravery X

Expand full comment
Ali Linz's avatar

I’m proud of you and so many others creating understanding without more hate. Thank you and keep it coming. Make it easy for everyone to understand in a simple, fact based way. 🥰👏🏻🙏🏻

Expand full comment
PAUL PELSSERS's avatar

I hear you, I see you & I stand with you Marnie!

Expand full comment
Amanda Rettig's avatar

This is brilliant Marnie. Thank you. I’m sharing it far and wide. Sending love

Amanda Rettig

Expand full comment
Carole P's avatar

Yes. This is our reality. Thanku for writing and voicing what we all feeling. Xx

Expand full comment
Carole P's avatar

Thank you for writing what we are all feeling. This is our reality and people need to know x

Expand full comment
Jo star's avatar

Articulately written. Thank you for taking the time to write and share 🙏❤️

Expand full comment
Linda Kugel's avatar

Amazingly written - Kol Hakavod. Exactly how I feel but could not articulate!!

Expand full comment
Marnie Perlstein's avatar

xoxoxox

Expand full comment
Leanne Moss's avatar

Marnie, I would join your advocacy group called THEY ALL HATE US because, yes, they do. It reminds me of the book 'People Love Dead Jews' by Dara Horn.

Expand full comment
Marnie Perlstein's avatar

Hi Leanne. Thanks so much for reading and commenting. Great to hear from you! Love Dara's book - and it's spot on. We are all alive and well and not so popular it would seem xx

Expand full comment
Dani's avatar

Marnie, this so brilliant. I am walking down Bondi road and I am crying. This hurts so deeply. But thank you for writing. We need it. 🙏🏻🙏🏻

Expand full comment
Julie Tylman's avatar

Marnie what a powerful message. You’ve summed up perfectly the horror, disgust and confusion our community is feeling and our disbelief and despair at the words and actions of the institutions meant to represent and protect us and at the twisted moral logic “like minded” progressives use to dismiss all of us. Well done.

Expand full comment
Kim Alster's avatar

Thank you Marnie - your message represents what is in all our hearts. Education is the only way forward. Our pain, our history, our struggle should not be a secret and thankfully you are sharing what desperately needs to be heard

Expand full comment
Barbara Fayman's avatar

I am so proud of you Marnie. Thank you for articulating our reality and what so many of us are feeling.

Expand full comment
Dannielle Taibel's avatar

Marnie, I am so very proud to call you my friend. Thank you for being our voice. Keep doing what you are doing as everybody out there needs to hear you.

Expand full comment